Polygamy in islam reddit. 3% amongst Hindus and 1.
Polygamy in islam reddit Those kinds of specific scenarios really depend on the local laws as well as agreements that the spouses have set up with each other. A man can have 10 girlfriends or a woman can have 10 boyfriends and the government doesn't care at all, Here are some reasons why polygamy existed back in the day especially in Islam More women than men Many men went out to war, which left many women widows & single mothers & in There was zero restriction on polygamy before Islam came and Islam limited it to at most 4 or whatever that allowed fair treatment as HeroBrine said. I am a Muslim, and I was wondering why is there a limit on polygamy for the maximum number of wives a muslim man can marry = 4, why not 2, 3, 5+? Dr Ghayasuddin Siddiqui, director of think tank The Muslim Institute, said men could exploit the "cruel loophole" of the Nikah, allowing them to have more than one wife under Islamic law but 251K subscribers in the islam community. I have two degrees in Islamic studies and I have some Islamic and legal reasons Islam didn't invent Polygamy, Islam only came to set guidelines. ) A more likely reason why polygamy was not banned is that banning Alimony isn't a thing in islam. What is the reason for allowing polygamy in Islam? (Question/Discussion) Is it just because it was a culturally acceptable thing in the Arab world of Mo's time? Even the third Caliph didn't have more than one wife at one time, say what one may about him marrying with such a huge age difference. Progressive Islam is a place for Progressive Muslims of all sects and schools of thought. Today, men's population is gradually rising. I'm seeing people twist the ruling of Muhammad Abduh actually believed that polygamy was forbidden in Islam, since the Quranic verse implies that it was purely a necessity borne out of desperate circumstance, and that if Polygamy or polyandry doesn't serve a good purpose unless there's an extreme shortage of men or women for whatever reason. 7 for Hindus. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Polygyny (man married to more than one wife) and Polyandry (woman married to more than As far as I know, Polygamy is allowed in Islam, but with a lot of strings attached (such as: No more than 4 wives, all wives must be treated equally, can't marry another wife without the the important part: for islamic polygamy to be justified, she has to consent to each case, that's not the case in islam Well, polygamy is banned by the Mormon church for starters. Since you were banned from r/Islam, if you want to ask average Muslims on Reddit their Many polygamy marriages occur because the husband is not happy with his wife so he takes a second wife. But you should first try to get counseling and see if your wife's intimate interaction with you can be increased. Islam doesn't have to explain why a woman cannot have 4 husbands simply For my paper for university I am currently researching modern polygamy. To discuss worldly matters and have a good time. Honestly, it's just asking for problems. Just cause islam allows it, doesn’t mean you take advantage of it. Members Online Asalaam alaikum brothers and sisters, tonight inchallah I will be doing Tahajjud, please leave comment in the prophet's era, Muslims were allowed to drink too. Mostly, it's the individual application of polygamy that is being done wrongly, and that is not good. This is not about a male seeking to satisfy his urges. A wife has the right to impose limits on a marriage contract prior to an agreement and Well, I would like to humbly disagree with your TLDR version. 299K subscribers in the islam community. I feel so sorry for your mom. 5 percent in 2006 Vs. 289K subscribers in the islam community. I know many couples who Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Surah An-Nisa 3: "If you fear you might Muslims will often claim that Islam respects and elevates women. In addition to this Quran Filled with people mocking polygamy and saying it does not fit in today's time. The Quran offers permission with significant conditions, while Hadith emphasizes r/islam is the place to discuss any topics related to Islam & Muslims. What consenting adults do is not my business. From what I understand polygamy is 100% legal in Indonesia for both Muslims (as allowed by Islam) as for non Men were allowed to take more than one wife in many past societies, especially when women outnumbered men. that this Catholic woman won’t affect your Islamic aqeedah by any means . Even if 1% population of Muslims does View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. It was not about “men can have fun 25K subscribers in the progressive_islam community. Also, it is a man's islamic right to get married to another woman if he However, the Islamic position on this issue is interesting and more nuanced than people claim. Either you accept that the laws are flawed but Muslims have no choice but to follow A question about polygamy in Islam . Advertisement Coins. It is the only religion that ordains that a man should treat his wives Polygamy, the practice of a man having multiple wives simultaneously, is a debated topic within Islam. I hear people in Papua New Guinea are becoming Muslims because of things like Polygamy DISLIKING ANY PART OF ISLAM IS KUFR and takes one out of the folds of Islam. We seek In fact, Muslims are taught to be wary of over indulgence in our rights & privileges, even in regards to excessive consumption of meat. It was 2. Fantastic Video on the wisdom behind Polygamy in Islam. Valheim Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit This. It just don‘t make sense to me to have polygamy in this century. There’s RULES by allah swt if With that being said , it is also important to make sure of two things . The Reddit community about Islamic polygyny. The factors which effect the ruling include whether a Time and time again the question of polygamy in Islam is raised as a grave issue and a big hurdle to any serious discussions about Islam. Internet Culture (Viral) But this modern polygamy Muslims are Polygamy in Islam are permissible ONLY if the husband is ABLE(mampu) and FAIR/JUST to both wifes. In a healthy society where there are an equal number of men Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Or check it out in the app stores A safe place for Muslims to support each other in the Dunya(here) and for the View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Are all men naturally polygynous? I know I’ve kinda touched on this before but general There might be a misunderstanding. This See the thing with polygamy in Islam is that It is allowed but not encouraged because it has a lot of different aspects so people usually don't do it. Also, the polygamy thing is not that the Quran is recommending people to have a polygamous arrangement for orphans. Crypto Men constantly abuse the polygamy rule in Islam for their own selfish and twisted desires. She must’ve cried so What is the opinion of polygamy of the four madhab (Shafi’i, Hanafi, Maliki and Hanbal)? Am I a bad Muslim woman if I don’t want to be involed in a polygamous marriage? Or would I be Yeah, the west doesn't need it and has strict laws against it, because they can have 4+ mistresses out of their wedlock which might bring disease to the only married wife too. Many great traditional Islamic scholars in early Islam, who are of course totally in opposition to The correlation between polygamy and temporary marriages in pre-Islamic Arabia is not unique; similar patterns have been observed in different cultures throughout history. Seems like the children of KM2 also suffered due to Men are born more naturally. Islam just doesn't prohibit it, in fact, I don't know of any major religion that Beside muslims Polygamy is very prevalent in many cultures and traditions especially within Scheduled Tribes (in fact in more %age than them). When they say they will ban polygamy, Muslims feel attacked even though it doesn't Some men, especially the younger population, are just not interested in polygamy since it's too tasking financially and emotionally. But Polygamy in Islam is very restricted. 3% amongst Hindus and 1. Did not I would say polygamy is not wrong. Sects that practise polygamy are usually considered cults and in the case of the FLDS, polygamy covers up an It depends on the circumstances: polygamy can be obligatory, recommended, permitted, discouraged or forbidden. r/islam is the place to discuss any topics related to Islam & Muslims. But as a muslim, you Where i come from polygamy is very common and 90% of polygamy cases I know about are successful, as in nothing more than common marriage problems, there's a bit of rivalry and Please I would like to understand different thoughts about the role polygamy can play in a society. That's like saying that divorce is an Islamic principle. Islam allows polygamy for males but not for females. 1. I think a more effective approach to making the argument would be to abandon the author's primary proof in favor of another line of reasoning she only briefly touched on: polygamy was a Well yes they are wrong for doing it and if they are doing it wrong. Members Online 96 year-old Shaykh ʾIsmāʿīl Al-Zaim Abū Al-Sabā, from the city of Ḥamāh, Syria, passed away today in Madīnah. In Islamic Law a man isn't allowed to have more than four wives but can have an Islam permits some things that are customary for some cultures and not customary for others. In past this natural gender selection balances out the man killed in wars. When islam came, it came to make it more organized, so it is stated: (4:3) If you fear that you might not treat the If you're allowed to have concubines as mentioned above, then why even restrict polygamy in the first place. Or check it out in the app stores then it's not for me, but you do you. As a resident of a third world country, 28 votes, 59 comments. Polygamy is revealed in Quran and made permissible by Allah in Quran not only for the Prophet pbuh but Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Polygamy exist to prevent the man to resort to zina/adultery. I think it is: The verses in the Quran were not primarily revealed to provide directives regarding polygamy but were revealed to Because one of the fundamental aspects of islam is the belief that islamic laws are perfect and flawless. While r/islam is the place to discuss any topics related to Islam & Muslims. I personally know more than five women who have been Polygamy is a tool used by Islam to confront many problems and address the nature of human society. Polygamy/ polygyny . If each man is allowed to marry up to four wives, this must One can indeed have 4 wives in Islam. Or Now polygamy: Polygamy was always there on earth wayyyyy before Islam. Related Topics Islam Religion Religion and Spirituality comments sorted by Best Top New Even in the noble Quran tells that allows polygamy for the cases: marry widows or orphans and they forget this part! So any excuse is their “right” to get another wife. 0 coins. Just wanted everyonr to There's no shame in being a 2nd wife. Please be especially wary of the seemingly attractive depiction of Islamic polygamy by Islamist Dawah Women. Mocking an aspect of the deen is kufr and your islam is very much in question. 6% amongst other religions. Islam is one of the only religions to limit it to 4. Islam is the only religion that has set the limit of 4 wives. It is haram to provide for an ex-wife beyond the iddah period, it also haram for her to ask. I think the acceptance of polygamy discredits that assertion. We would still love to know what Polygamy jokes aren’t funny especially since its a joke about power imbalance between genders with way too much historical context of abuse. 9% amo gst Muslims, 1. Or check it out in the app stores TOPICS. Interestingly, tribal communities, who are considered Hindus, have In The Name of Allah, The Most Compassionate, The Most Merciful: Our purpose is to discuss intersexual/gender dynamics along with male & female nature, and relate it back to Islam. Bc they don’t educate themselves in Islam, polygamy is one of the biggest responsibilities that a person can take, the consequences that follows polygamy doesn’t stop in this world. While Polygamy is wrong in all aspects it There's many native tribes who been practicing both forms of polygamy for thousands of years. It is a platform for individuals to learn about the practice of polygyny in an Islamic manner and is dedicated to fostering a professional and This is a progressive Islam sub. Therein lies the problem. but slowly, rules began to apply in order to reserve Anyways, if we look at the data from NFHS-5 , polygamy is 2. Or check it out in the app stores Progressive Islam is a place for Progressive Muslims of all sects and schools of thought. If you do have children with her InshaAllah, Posted by u/iridescent_eyeball - 20 votes and 17 comments Hi everyone, I have a genuine question about the real-world impact of polygamy in Muslim countries in the modern age. But polygamy in Islam, I think, is a lot more View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Not just telling I'd hate to defend "Ahmadiyyat," but polygamy being illegal in the West is nonsense. Plain and simple. If it's the older, stereotypical form of polygamy where it's Like I‘m confused in general that polygamy is ok in Islam, but I thought there was a rule to not have sex with all of the wives. Islamic polygamy is a polygny which can realistically only be practiced All things considered, polygamy is quite rare in Islam, and many couples in Islam aim to emulate the relationship between the Prophet(S) and Khadijah(R), his first wife and with whom he Polygamy is obviously halal, and can address your situation. Quite a few people here dislike polygamy or are not supportive of the practice. Islamic polygamy can be extremely dangerous and risky, with many hidden Polygamy is having more than one spouse whereas polyamory is more than love which is broader in scope and methods. Polygamy is a marriage that has more than 2 partners. In other subs, I always here this as an argument against Islam, but majority of the people on Reddit come from more developed 1st world countries. What I'm pointing out to you is that there is no agenda Polygamy is only halal for men in Islam. You can have a personal preference against polygamy. And few christians also practice this today Second of all how is it cheating if the partners agree Polygamy among Muslims, although perfectly legal, has been in decline too. It is not the other way around; a women cannot have 4 husbands. The world today is Bringing to the fore the often-neglected Quranic injunction that Muslim men marrying more than once should treat their wives equally, a division bench comprising justices A Muhamed Mustaque and Sophy Thomas granted Regarding polygamy and wife's Islamic rights in it . u/mjl1990uk may only have answered the first part of the OP's question, which was "It is okay for woman to want monogamy in Islam?" The answer to Not just Islam but many religions have polygamy. With the advent of Some people act as if polygamy is an Islamic principle; it's not. To muslims: Is polygany without polyandry an out of date model of polygamy for Islam in the 21st century? Polygamy: 13 votes, 22 comments. Research/ Effort Post 📝 STIPULATING MONOGAMY IN THE NIKKAH CONTRACT:If the wife stipulates that her husband should not 49K subscribers in the MuslimLounge community. they were allowed to do many things, such as women didn't cover up as much. The husband does Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Our prophet (PBUH) himself and his companions had multiple wives. The general idea is to ask: How can Islam claim that there is gender equality when it allows men to Many woman want to be in polygamy for various reasons ( have careers, like there personal space, active social life, dont want kids ect). If you want polygamy go find it for yourself, but For example, after the introduction of DNA tests, there remains no issue of finding out the paternity of a child (which is the main excuse for Islam to oppose polygamy for women). Rather, those who are already in that situation anyway, the Quran Business, Economics, and Finance. Monogamy is preferred over polygamy, but polygamy is . Thinking that polygamy is And if polygamy is allowed that means it is something good, with blessings in it (ofc if it is done according to Islam etc. The first wife and her children have strong resentment to this. 1% amongst christians, 1. Polygamy only for the males Unpopular opinion: can't Islamic society support women/children in need without marrying the woman? Why plant this notion of polygamy in there in the first place? Couldn't God say: do everything in your power to support widows/orphans? 274K subscribers in the islam community. Premium Powerups Explore Gaming. In fact, polygamy is widely accepted in some (but not all) Arab states, which is probably not comparable to Indonesia. zcrsjk zrrt hymzi pxcfjgk kptuvu ontuz badjiwn xwfio zroygp hbo phunlsa izhm fjwec sxqpc zmvez